Skip to content
JRJeff ReynoldsCompass · Seattle
Photo Unavailable
Active

Listed by David A. Kelley, Kidder Mathews

Multi Family
Type
1963
Year built
23,319 sq ft
Lot
406
Days on market

About this property

JUST LISTED - Garden Square apartments, a 21-unit multifamily property centrally located at 219 12th Ave SE, Puyallup, WA 98372. Featuring large average floor plans of 934 SF — well above typical unit sizes for comparable product in the submarket — Garden Square provides a clear value-add pathway through a continued renovation program, including updated kitchens, bathrooms, flooring, and modern finishes tailored to today's renter expectations. New ownership can continue this in-place renovation strategy to increase monthly rents by approximately 12%, unlocking substantial gains in net operating income as units turn. In addition to its generously sized floor plans, the property benefits from a centralized Puyallup location, offering convenient access to neighborhood retail / employment centers / downtown Puyallup, positioning the asset to appeal to a broad renter base seeking larger, more livable units at accessible rents. Garden Square represents a high-quality foundation for continued value - add execution, with Garden Square's oversized unit layouts serving as a key differentiator from the market's typical unit mix. Its size, location, and renovation runway make it well-suited to support both existing tenant retention and rent growth as the improvement program continues.

Location & commute

Add a destination (work, gym, school) for directions and drive time.

Directions

Property details

Listing details

Listing number
#2589855
Listed
October 1, 2026
Days on market
406 (includes a prior listing period)

Unit & building

Stories in building
2
Units in building
21

Parking

Total spaces
20

Construction

Year built
1963
Style
56 - 10+ Units
Structure
Multi Family
Roof
Composition

Heating & cooling

Heating
Baseboard
Cooling
None
Energy source
Electric

Flooring

Flooring
Vinyl Plank

Lot

Lot size
23,319 sq ft

Terms

Terms offered
Conventional

Utilities

Sewer
Sewer Connected
Power
Kidder Mathews

Schools

District
Puyallup

What stands out to you?

Mark features you love or could do without. Saved on this device to tune what you see.

  • Multi Family
  • Composition
  • Baseboard
  • None
  • Electric
  • Vinyl Plank
  • Conventional
  • Sewer Connected

Listing history

  1. Listed

    $4,000,000

    October 1, 2026

Derived from current MLS listing fields. Full multi-cycle status history is on the roadmap.

Payment estimate

An estimate to help you plan, not a loan offer or financial advice.

Est. monthly

$23,293

Principal & interest
$20,226
Property tax (est.)
$3,067

Assumes $800,000 down (20%), a $3,200,000 loan at 6.5% over 30 years. Property tax is an estimated figure, not MLS data (verify with the county assessor). Excludes insurance, PMI, and closing costs. Not a commitment to lend or financial advice.

Similar nearby listings

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of October 1, 2026 at 2:00 PM PDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.