Skip to content
JRJeff ReynoldsCompass · Seattle

Listed by Jennifer Berg, Real Broker LLC

4
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
3,982
Square feet
$207
Per sq ft
Single Family Residence
Type
1900
Year built
6,534 sq ft
Lot
46
Days on market

About this property

Stunning, lovingly restored 3-story home in the heart of downtown Puyallup on market for the very first time! Built in 1900 by the Methodist Church, this home was a parsonage until the mid 1960s. Its original hardwood floors and millwork have been beautifully refinished. Expansive living area with built-in electric fireplace, formal dining room with gorgeous built-in cabinets. Modern kitchen with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, floor to ceiling cabinets, and a huge walk-in pantry! A wet bar and additional living space with beautiful ceiling beams make this home perfect for entertaining. Also on the main floor - a private home office with separate entrance, making working from home a breeze! Upstairs you’ll find four large bedrooms, a large full bathroom with built-in cabinets, and a spacious laundry room bursting with natural light. Head up to the 3rd floor for an additional bedroom, full bathroom, large rec room and views of Mt Rainier! A pass-thru garage w/endless driveway, a fully fenced backyard, a dog washing station, and 500sqft basement for even more storage. Own a piece of history, with all the modern amenities you could ever imagine - All of this in walking distance to parks, shops, restaurants, the Fairgrounds - and the Sounder Station! Make it yours today!

Location & commute

Add a destination (work, gym, school) for directions and drive time.

Directions

Property details

Listing details

Listing number
#2531342
Listed
May 28, 2026
Days on market
46
Price per sq ft
$207
Original list price
$849,950

Unit & building

Unit levels
Multi/Split

Parking

Parking
DrivewayDetached Garage
Covered spaces
1
Total spaces
5

Views

View
MountainsTerritorial

Construction

Year built
1900
Style
15 - Multi Level
Structure
House
Roof
Composition

Heating & cooling

Heating
RadiatorRecirculation PumpWall Furnace
Cooling
None
Energy source
ElectricNatural Gas

Interior features

Features
Ceiling Fan(s)Dbl Pane/Storm WindowDining RoomFireplacePantryWater HeaterWet BarWine/Beverage Refrigerator
Fireplaces
1
Fireplace type
Electric

Flooring

Flooring
HardwoodLaminate

Appliances

Appliances
DishwasherDisposalDryerMicrowaveRefrigeratorStove(s)/Range(s)Washer

Community & building features

Bus line nearby
Yes

Lot

Lot features
CurbsPavedSidewalk
Lot size
6,534 sq ft

Terms

Terms offered
CashConventionalFHAVA Loan

Utilities

Water
City of Puyallup
Sewer
City of Puyallup
Power
Puget Sound Energy

Schools

District
Puyallup
Elementary
Meeker Elem
Middle
Kalles Jnr High
High
Puyallup High

What stands out to you?

Mark features you love or could do without. Saved on this device to tune what you see.

  • Multi/Split
  • Driveway
  • Detached Garage
  • Mountains
  • Territorial
  • House
  • Composition
  • Radiator
  • Recirculation Pump
  • Wall Furnace
  • None
  • Electric

Listing history

  1. Listed

    $849,950

    May 28, 2026

  2. Current price

    $824,950

Derived from current MLS listing fields. Full multi-cycle status history is on the roadmap.

Payment estimate

An estimate to help you plan, not a loan offer or financial advice.

Est. monthly

$4,803

Principal & interest
$4,171
Property tax (est.)
$632

Assumes $164,990 down (20%), a $659,960 loan at 6.5% over 30 years. Property tax is an estimated figure, not MLS data (verify with the county assessor). Excludes insurance, PMI, and closing costs. Not a commitment to lend or financial advice.

Similar nearby listings

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of July 14, 2026 at 12:45 AM PDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.